Listed in chronological order
| Player | Year | Team Name | Position | Team |
| Paul Petrich Jr. | 1953 | Collier’s Little All-American Team | n/a | |
| Bobby Schwarze | 1957 | Academic All-American | QB | 1st |
| Paul Maguire | 1959 | Associated Press | P | 3rd |
| Vince Petno | 1963 | Associated Press | R | 3rd |
| 1963 | Academic All-American | R | 1st | |
| John Small | 1969 | The Sporting News | LB | 1st |
| 1969 | Associated Press | LB | 2nd | |
| Kenny Caldwell | 1978 | Academic All-American | 1st | |
| 1977 | Academic All-American | 1st | ||
| 1976 | Academic All-American | 1st | ||
| Brian Ruff | 1976 | Associated Press | LB | 1st |
| 1976 | United Press International | LB | 2nd | |
| 1975 | Associated Press | LB | 2nd | |
| Stump Mitchell | 1980 | Associated Press | RB | 3rd |
| Jim Ettari | 1984 | Kodak | 1st | |
| 1982 | Kodak | 1st | ||
| Jim Gabrish | 1985 | Associated Press | 1st | |
| 1985 | Kodak | 1st | ||
| 1984 | Associated Press | 2nd | ||
| Scott Thompson | 1987 | Associated Press | 3rd | |
| 1986 | Associated Press | 1st | ||
| Tom Frooman | 1988 | Academic All-American | 1st | |
| 1987 | Academic All-American | 1st | ||
| Carlos Avalos | 1988 | Associated Press | 1st | |
| 1988 | Kodak | 1st | ||
| 1988 | Walter Camp | 1st | ||
| 1988 | Sports Network | 1st | ||
| 1988 | Football Gazette | 1st | ||
| J.J. Davis | 1990 | Walter Camp | 1st | |
| 1990 | Associated Press | 2nd | ||
| DeRhon Robinson | 1990 | Kodak | OL | 1st |
| Lester Smith | 1992 | Associated Press | DB | 1st |
| 1992 | Kodak | 1st | ||
| 1992 | Walter Camp | 1st | ||
| 1992 | Sports Network | 1st | ||
| 1991 | Walter Camp | 1st | ||
| 1991 | Sports Network | 1st | ||
| Carey Cash | 1992 | Associated Press | 1st | |
| 1992 | Walter Camp | 1st | ||
| 1992 | Sports Network | 1st | ||
| Torrencey Forney | 1992 | Associated Press | 2nd | |
| 1992 | Walter Camp | 1st | ||
| 1992 | Sports Network | 2nd | ||
| Lance Hansen | 1992 | Associated Press | 3rd | |
| 1992 | Walter Camp | 1st | ||
| 1992 | Sports Network | 1st | ||
| Everette Sands | 1992 | Sports Network | 2nd | |
| Levi Davis | 1994 | American Football Coaches Association | ||
| Scott Belcher | 1995 | Sports Network | 3rd | |
| Brad Keeney | 1995 | American Football Coaches Association | ||
| Carlos Frank | 1997 | Sports Network | 1st | |
| Travis Stephens | 2001 | I-AA Athletic Directors Association | 1st | |
| 2001 | Don Hansen’s | 3rd | ||
| 2000 | I-AA Athletic Directors Association | 1st | ||
| 2000 | Don Hansen’s | 3rd | ||
| 2000 | Sports Network | 3rd | ||
| Andre Roberts | 2008 | Associated Press | 1st | |
| 2008 | American Football Coaches Association | 1st | ||
| 2007 | Associated Press | 3rd | ||
| Mike Sellers | 2012 | American Football Coaches Association | 1st | |
| 2012 | Sports Network | 1st | ||
Honorable Mention All-Americans |
||||
| Orville L. Rogers 1937 | ||||
| Andrew A. Victor 1942 | ||||
| Conrad Tuza 1956 | ||||
| Bobby Schwarze 1957 | ||||
| Charlie Brendle 1962 | ||||
| Bob Carson 1972 | ||||
| Early Eastburn 1961 | ||||
| Bill Gilgo 1961 | ||||
| Joe Missar 1964 | ||||
| Ken Diaz 1968 | ||||
| Joe Isaac 1968 | ||||
| Jimmy King 1970 | ||||
| Bob Carson 1972 | ||||
| David J. Kreber 1979 | ||||
| Joe Pipczynski 1982 | ||||
| Joe Pipczynski 1996 | ||||