Listed in chronological order
| YEAR | LAST NAME | FIRST NAME | POS | 1st TEAM | 2nd TEAM & HM | NOTABLE |
| 1913 | Folger | Billy | RH | 1st | ||
| Weeks | Johnny | FB | 1st | |||
| Sheppard | Francis | LT | 2nd | |||
| 1914 | Sheppard | Francis | LT | 1st | ||
| Switzer | Henry | FB | 1st | |||
| Weeks | Francis | RH | 1st | |||
| 1915 | Henderson | E | 1st | |||
| James | Bill | C | 1st | |||
| Weeks | Johnny | HB | 1st | |||
| Jeter | Harold | E | 2nd | |||
| Switzer | Henry | FB | 2nd | |||
| 1916 | Jeffords | Quinn | RT | 1st | ||
| Jeter | Harold | RE | 1st | |||
| Switzer | Henry | FB | 1st | |||
| Weeks | Johnny | QB | 1st | |||
| 1917 | Taber | Al | RT | 2nd | ||
| 1919 | Crouch | John | RE | 1st | ||
| 1920 | Frost | John | QB | 1st | ||
| 1921 | Gramling | JL | RT | 1st | ||
| Frost | John | E | Hon Men | |||
| 1923 | Wagener | Freddy | T | 1st | ||
| 1924 | Weeks | Teddy | QB | 1st | ||
| Wagener | Freddy | LT | 2nd | |||
| Kilpatrick | George | HB | Hon Men | |||
| Brinker | Clarence | C | Hon Men | |||
| Hogrefe | HB | Hon Men | ||||
| 1925 | Berry | Richard | B | 1st | ||
| Seabrook | Ephie | RG | 1st | |||
| 1926 | Figg | Eugene | LT | 1st | ||
| Sweetenberg | Raymond | RE | 1st | |||
| Denham | Andrew | E | Hon Men | |||
| King | Bull | T | Hon Men | |||
| Seabrook | Ephie | G | Hon Men | |||
| Still | Henry | G | Hon Men | |||
| 1927 | King | Bull | T | 1st | ||
| Blanding | Donald | B | 1st | |||
| King | Dick | E | 1st | |||
| 1928 | King | Dick | E | 1st | ||
| Oglesby | Walter | G | 2nd | |||
| 1929 | Oglesby | Walter | G | 1st | ||
| Wilson | Tom “Pop” | QB | Hon Men | |||
| Willard | Bill | RE | Hon Men | |||
| 1930 | Oglesby | Walter | RG | Hon Men | ||
| Holland | Charles | LT | Hon Men | |||
| 1931 | Jennings | Anthony | QB | 1st | ||
| McIntosh | Edwin | FB | 1st | |||
| Willard | Charles | E | Hon Men | |||
| Holland | Charles | T | Hon Men | |||
| Ogilvie | J.M. | G | Hon Men | |||
| Watts | Elmer | G | Hon Men | |||
| 1932 | Jennings | Larkin | QB | 1st | ||
| King | Hugh | E | Hon Men | |||
| Symmes | Billy | FB | Hon Men | |||
| 1933 | Quarterman | Charlie | HB | 1st | ||
| Symmes | Billy | C | 2nd | |||
| 1934 | Symmes | Billy | C | 1st | ||
| Levi | George | E | Hon Men | |||
| Townsend | Carlos | E | Hon Men | |||
| Jenkins | John | T | Hon Men | |||
| Lowe | MacDonald | G | Hon Men | |||
| Fonvielle | Edward | G | Hon Men | |||
| Hall | Andy | QB | Hon Men | |||
| Ferguson | Arthur | B | Hon Men | |||
| Faulkner | Thomas | B | Hon Men | |||
| Baker | Ralph | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1935 | Hall | Andy | B | 1st | ||
| Lowe | Mac | LG | 2nd | |||
| McCredie | Claude | B | 2nd | |||
| 1936 | Rogers | Orville | RT | 1st | ||
| Smith | Chet | HB | 1st | |||
| Sabados | Andy | FB | 2nd | |||
| David | Bob | E | Hon Men | |||
| Harshbarger | Roger | G | Hon Men | |||
| Miller | John | C | Hon Men | |||
| Robinson | Kooksie | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1937 | Aston | Walter | G | 1st | ||
| King | Francis | RE | 1st | |||
| Robinson | Kooksie | HB | 1st | |||
| Sabados | Andy | C | 1st | |||
| Rogers | Orville | T | 2nd | |||
| Manley | Walter | E | Hon Men | |||
| Rogers | Hugh | T | Hon Men | |||
| Sabados | Andy | G | Hon Men | |||
| Harshbarger | Roger | G | Hon Men | |||
| McNeil | Frank | QB | Hon Men | |||
| Smith | Nathaniel | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1938 | Edwards | Graham | B | 1st | ||
| Sabados | Andy | C | 2nd | |||
| David | Bob | E | Hon Men | |||
| Harshbarger | Roger | T | Hon Men | |||
| Eichholz | Jerome | T | Hon Men | |||
| Peebles | Emory | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1939 | David | Bob | E | 2nd | ||
| Edwards | Graham | B | 2nd | |||
| Burrows | John | E | Hon Men | |||
| Shealy | Francis | T | Hon Men | |||
| DesChamps | Robert | G | Hon Men | |||
| Stewart | John | G | Hon Men | |||
| Spain | Willian | C | Hon Men | |||
| Kierstead | Doug | C | Hon Men | |||
| Browning | Elmer | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1940 | Suitt | Ben | E | 2nd | ||
| Kierstead | Doug | E | Hon Men | |||
| Lockwood | Eddie | E | Hon Men | |||
| Kennedy | Henry | G | Hon Men | |||
| Foster | E.L. “Hank” | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1941 | Belser | Ritchie | G | 2nd | ||
| Damon | John | T | 2nd | |||
| Victor | Andy | B | 2nd | |||
| Kierstead | Doug | E | Hon Men | |||
| Campbell | Frank Z. | E | Hon Men | |||
| Thompson | Waddy | T | Hon Men | |||
| Birkner | John | G | Hon Men | |||
| Wolf | Paul | G | Hon Men | |||
| Salvato | Albert | B | Hon Men | |||
| Dukes | Basil | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1942 | Victor | Andy | B | 1st | ||
| Limbird | Charles | G | 2nd | |||
| Damon | John | G | 2nd | |||
| Dukes | Basil | B | 2nd | |||
| Marcinko | Tom | E | Hon Men | |||
| Wolf | Paul | T | Hon Men | |||
| Bell | Langley | G | Hon Men | |||
| Alexander | Andy | G | Hon Men | |||
| Salvato | Al | B | Hon Men | |||
| Gold | Marty | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1946 | Henderson | Bill | G | 1st | ||
| Salvato | Al | B | 3rd | |||
| Foxworth | Gene | E | Hon Men | |||
| Lancaster | W.B. | E | Hon Men | |||
| Margavage | Ralph | T | Hon Men | |||
| Clowes | Kay | G | Hon Men | |||
| Haltiwanger | Earl | C | Hon Men | |||
| Dunfee | Luther | B | Hon Men | |||
| Shahid | Wadere S. | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1947 | Henderson | Bill | G | 2nd | ||
| Foxworth | Gene | E | 3rd | |||
| Shahid | Wadere | B | 3rd | |||
| Clowes | Kay | G | Hon Men | |||
| Dunfee | Luke | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1948 | Whelan | Jim | E | 3rd | ||
| Foxworth | Gene | E | Hon Men | |||
| Drawdy | Ken | T | Hon Men | |||
| Henderson | Bill | G | Hon Men | |||
| Matthews | Dale | C | Hon Men | |||
| Pinckney | Lucian | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1949 | Brownlow | Harmon | E | Hon Men | ||
| Ohlandt | Gunner | E | Hon Men | |||
| Whelan | Jim | T | Hon Men | |||
| Webster | Clark | T | Hon Men | |||
| Huddle | Jack | G | Hon Men | |||
| Malacarne | Albert | G | Hon Men | |||
| Haltiwanger | Rufus | C | Hon Men | |||
| Brugh | Walter | B | Hon Men | |||
| Chandler | Jack | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1950 | DeLuca | Jerry | E | 1st | ||
| Rubino | Sam | C | 2nd | |||
| Friedlin | Buddy | B | 2nd | |||
| McGinn | Bob | T | Hon Men | |||
| Huddle | Jack | G | Hon Men | |||
| Doss | Jim | G | Hon Men | |||
| Bohlen | Alfred | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1951 | Mamajek | John | B | 2nd | ||
| McGinn | Bob | T | 3rd | |||
| Zelinski | Dick | T | 3rd | |||
| Rubino | Sam | C | 3rd | |||
| Dyches | Bonsil | T | Hon Men | |||
| Petrich | Paul | T | Hon Men | |||
| Baldwin | Bill | G | Hon Men | |||
| Doss | Jim | G | Hon Men | |||
| Malacarne | Al | G | Hon Men | |||
| Williams | Bill | G | Hon Men | |||
| Bozeman | Curtis | B | Hon Men | |||
| Chandler | Jack | B | Hon Men | |||
| Chapman | Paul | B | Hon Men | |||
| Friedlin | Buddy | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1953 | Thayer | Jerry | T | 2nd | ||
| Tyson | Jim | E | 3rd | |||
| Renken | Ralph | T | Hon Men | |||
| Rierson | Duby | B | Hon Men | |||
| Blanton | Buford | B | Hon Men | |||
| 1955 | Tyson | Jim | E | 1st | ||
| 1957 | Schwarze | Bobby | QB | 1st | ||
| 1959 | Maguire | Paul | E | 1st | ||
| 1960 | Eastburn | Earley | HB | 1st | ||
| Garrison | George | C | 1st | |||
| Rakowski | Harry | T | 1st | |||
| 1961 | Gilgo | Bill | E | 1st | ||
| 1962 | Dice | Gene | G | 1st | ||
| 1963 | Petno | Vince | E | 1st | ||
| 1964 | Bills | Dick | E | 1st | ||
| Foster | Mitch | T | 1st | |||
| Lane | Mike | RB | 1st | |||
| Missar | Joe | G | 1st | |||
| 1965 | Grant | Francis | DB | 1st | ||
| 1966 | Latini | Larry | T | 1st | ||
| McCombs | Cal | DB | 1st | |||
| 1967 | Gettys | Alex | T | 1st | ||
| Isaac | Joe | DB | 1st | |||
| Small | John | LB | 1st | |||
| 1968 | Diaz | Ken | DE | 1st | ||
| Isaac | Joe | DB | 1st | |||
| McMillan | Jim | RB | 1st | |||
| 1969 | Bryan | Phil | DB | 1st | ||
| Duncan | Bob | RB | 1st | |||
| Glover | Marion | T | 1st | |||
| Watson | Billy | SE | 1st | |||
| 1970 | Dease | Don | G | 1st | ||
| Duncan | Bob | RB | 1st | |||
| King | Jim | DB | 1st | |||
| Lee | Jim | DE | 1st | |||
| Varnadoe | Jeff | DB | 1st | |||
| 1971 | Baima | Brian | SE | 1st | ||
| Davitt | Mike | T | 1st | |||
| Hall | Jon | RB | 1st | |||
| Hutto | Pat | G | 1st | |||
| Lynch | Harry | QB | 1st | |||
| Varnadoe | Jeff | DB | 1st | |||
| 1972 | Carson | Bob | RB | 1st | ||
| Lynch | Harry | QB | 1st | |||
| 1973 | Cicoria | Tony | DG | 1st | ||
| Holt | Rusty | DB | 1st | |||
| 1974 | Johnson | Andrew | RB | 1st | ||
| Ruff | Brian | LB | 1st | |||
| 1975 | Caldwell | Kenny | P | 1st | ||
| Ferguson | Ralph | DB | 1st | |||
| Ruff | Brian | LB | 1st | |||
| Starks | Tony | DG | 1st | |||
| Sumner | Paul | T | 1st | |||
| 1976 | Caldwell | Kenny | P | 1st | ||
| Ferguson | Ralph | DB | 1st | |||
| Ruff | Brian | LB | 1st | Player of the Year | ||
| Starks | Tony | DG | 1st | |||
| 1977 | Caldwell | Kenny | P | 1st | ||
| Gillis | Paul | DB | 1st | |||
| Starks | Tony | DG | 1st | |||
| 1978 | Gillis | Paul | DB | 1st | ||
| 1979 | Gillis | Paul | DB | 1st | ||
| 1980 | Mitchell | Stump | TB | 1st | ||
| McLarty | Dale | DE | 1st | |||
| Slawson | Mark | WR | 1st | |||
| McGroaty | Pat | OG | 1st | |||
| Fedrick | Tom | C | 1st | |||
| Carter | Chris | DB | 1st | |||
| 1981 | Miller | Danny | RB | 1st | ||
| Walker | Byron | FL | 1st | |||
| Curry | Kelly | LB | 1st | |||
| Ettari | Jim | NG | 1st | |||
| 1982 | Ettari | Jim | DT | 1st | ||
| Pipczynski | Joe | OT | 1st | |||
| 1983 | West | Bill | TE | 1st | ||
| 1984 | Frazier | Victor | WR | 1st | ||
| Gabrish | Jim | OT | 1st | |||
| Hill | Robert | QB | 1st | |||
| 1985 | Gabrish | Jim | OT | 1st | ||
| 1986 | Thompson | Scott | DT | 1st | Captain of State Team | |
| 1988 | Avalos | Carlos | OG | 1st | ||
| Brown | Gene | QB | 1st | |||
| Cauthen | J.D. | DB | 1st | |||
| Donley | Trent | TE | 1st | |||
| Long | Pee | LB | 1st | |||
| Johnson | Adrian | FB | 1st | |||
| 1989 | Walker | Shannon | DB | 1st | ||
| 1991 | Cash | Cary | OT | 1st | ||
| Sands | Everette | FB | 1st | |||
| Smith | Lester | DB | 1st | |||
| 1992 | Cash | Cary | OT | 1st | ||
| Copeland | Brett | C | 1st | |||
| Douglas | Jack | QB | 1st | Offensive Player of Year | ||
| Fagan | Marty | TE | 1st | |||
| Hanson | Lance | OG | 1st | |||
| Sands | Everette | FB | 1st | |||
| Smith | Lester | DB | 1st | Defensive Player of Year | ||
| 1999 | Barley | Jason | TE | 1st | ||
| Frank | Carlos | WR | 1st | |||
| 2006 | Lawson | Joshu | DB | 1st | ||
| 2007 | Broughton | Trevar | DE | 1st | ||
| Lawson | Joshu | DB | 1st | |||
| Rowell | Andrew | LB | 1st | |||
| 2008 | DeHaven | Dan | OL | 1st | ||
| Reese | Terrence | DL | 1st | |||
| Roberts | Andre | WR | 1st | |||
| 2009 | DeHaven | Dan | OL | 1st | ||
| Roberts | Andre | WR | 1st | |||
Note: The above information on All State Players is from The State Newspaper (Columbia, SC)